|
Certainly an ode to her love of nineteenth century literature, Setterfield hits the mark with with her debut novel. The plot is well thought out, with a cast of interesting characters, an atmosphere that is a mixture of lush and foreboding settings, and a decent dose of mystery and intrigue to boot. Well worth a read.
I brought "The Thirteenth Tale" on vacation with me and I was finished before I left. Diane Setterfield's got this ghost story/mystery packed full of curiosities that will have you searching for the answers until the end.
There were too many elements that didn't fit together, too many questions left unanswered. A lot of loose ends were left, but not in the purposeful way a skillful writer might leave his or her readers thinking after the book ends.
I had high hopes for this book, so I was disappointed when I wasn't immediately engaged. As I read on, I found that I did want to keep reading.
I am an avid reader and usually get really wrapped up in the books I read. So much of the ending of this book just didn't make sense.
I kept waiting for some kind of major plot twist or revelation. I guess you can say the plot twist came, but it was very disappointed.
Instead, I felt like these plot holes were a result of the fact that much of what Setterfield tried to do with this book just didn't work. So although I found some of the characters intriguing, and although I thought the book showed a lot of promise and potential, I was ultimately disappointed.
If it wasn't a book club pick I would have dumped it about page 100. I just don't get it. this was one of the most painful books I have ever read. Very tedious read - so tired of overrated reviews and fiction with a total lack of substance. Big waste of time.
I have a new favorite book. I want to read it again and again and again1.
|